WHY SOCIALISM WORKS?
just asking.
just asking.
2 users upvote it!
7 answers
If you look at the social cross-section, the vast majority is, let's call it, at a lower level of wealth. In addition, there are a number of beliefs and "truths" instilled from an early age by the environment. According to these truths, the rich are thieves and dishonest tormentors, and the rest are honest, poor people left at the mercy of the former. That is why socialist slogans about equality, social responsibility, common good, common property, central supervision are successful and work. Like carrots and sticks, people become tools in the hands of those who proclaim these slogans, and at the same time they feel part of a certain community.
If you look at the social cross-section, the vast majority is, let's call it, at a lower level of wealth. In addition, there are a number of beliefs and "truths" instilled from an early age by the environment. According to these truths, the rich are thieves and dishonest tormentors, and the rest are honest, poor people left at the mercy of the former. That is why socialist slogans about equality, social responsibility, common good, common property, central supervision are successful and work. Like carrots and sticks, people become tools in the hands of those who proclaim these slogans, and at the same time they feel part of a certain community.
Machine translated
6 likes
it depends how you look at it :) for some it works and for others it doesn't, so asking the question in this way is not very precise and I would even say that it is biased because we assume in advance that it works :D I agree with Zbigniew regarding the implementation of certain targeted behaviors on building beliefs about the common good, about ubiquitous justice, about all the ideal scenarios that socialism has chosen as a weapon to promote itself. Certainly, growing up in socialist-prone soil does not help to see the great harm that this kind of thinking can create, and that belief in a universally just system is the only right option for their representatives. The very concept of "justice" means something completely different for each of us, and we should not forget this. Diversity, not equality, is what keeps us moving forward in evolution as a species. On the other hand, many of us would like to live in a friendly environment, where by "selling our usefulness" social form, e.g. professional or charity activity or any other on the conventionally called "equal" terms, it would be a nice perspective, which, unfortunately, the supporters of socialism, in my humble opinion, I think they are overusing it. Only, would it cause our development? It's worth thinking about it. Let's not forget about our taxonomic affiliation which is the animal kingdom where the rules can be very brutal. Of course, we have a brain that should be used in the best possible way and let's stick to it :) From the perspective of a thinking person, I believe that it is important to approach the social dependencies that surround us critically and not to focus on "songs about an ideal fair system" but to build our personal capital. In other words, working at the bottom or a drop hollows out a rock or a 1000-mile journey starts with the first step is a philosophy that can help us understand ourselves and thus the world. The promise of an ideal system straight from a soap opera or a fairy tale about a just, equal kingdom in the case of such a diverse individual as man is, to put it mildly, a fraud that many unfortunately still fall for. And it is our imperfection in the form of naivety, hope, but also laziness, "tumivism" and also "bestialism" in many communities that makes socialism very much alive.
it depends how you look at it :) for some it works and for others it doesn't, so asking the question in this way is not very precise and I would even say that it is biased because we assume in advance that it works :D I agree with Zbigniew regarding the implementation of certain targeted behaviors on building beliefs about the common good, about ubiquitous justice, about all the ideal scenarios that socialism has chosen as a weapon to promote itself. Certainly, growing up in socialist-prone soil does not help to see the great harm that this kind of thinking can create, and that belief in a universally just system is the only right option for their representatives. The very concept of "justice" means something completely different for each of us, and we should not forget this. Diversity, not equality, is what keeps us moving forward in evolution as a species. On the other hand, many of us would like to live in a friendly environment, where by "selling our usefulness" social form, e.g. professional or charity activity or any other on the conventionally called "equal" terms, it would be a nice perspective, which, unfortunately, the supporters of socialism, in my humble opinion, I think they are overusing it. Only, would it cause our development? It's worth thinking about it. Let's not forget about our taxonomic affiliation which is the animal kingdom where the rules can be very brutal. Of course, we have a brain that should be used in the best possible way and let's stick to it :) From the perspective of a thinking person, I believe that it is important to approach the social dependencies that surround us critically and not to focus on "songs about an ideal fair system" but to build our personal capital. In other words, working at the bottom or a drop hollows out a rock or a 1000-mile journey starts with the first step is a philosophy that can help us understand ourselves and thus the world. The promise of an ideal system straight from a soap opera or a fairy tale about a just, equal kingdom in the case of such a diverse individual as man is, to put it mildly, a fraud that many unfortunately still fall for. And it is our imperfection in the form of naivety, hope, but also laziness, "tumivism" and also "bestialism" in many communities that makes socialism very much alive.
Machine translated
3 likes
Socialism is a perverted form of solidarity. It is solidarity that works, and evil, as usual, distorts what works turns 180 degrees so that it becomes the opposite and disgusts what is right and is sneeringly happy about it, hideously, Purpose: when someone points to solidarity, so that you can easily be accused of calling for socialism, and there is one fundamental difference, as between forcing and encouraging.
Socialism is a perverted form of solidarity. It is solidarity that works, and evil, as usual, distorts what works turns 180 degrees so that it becomes the opposite and disgusts what is right and is sneeringly happy about it, hideously, Purpose: when someone points to solidarity, so that you can easily be accused of calling for socialism, and there is one fundamental difference, as between forcing and encouraging.
Machine translated
3 likes
Maybe someone living in Venezuela will answer you why it "works"...
Maybe someone living in Venezuela will answer you why it "works"...
2 likes
This question is difficult to answer because there are many factors that can influence the effectiveness of socialism. However, the most common reasons why socialism can work successfully are:
1) social justice - the system allows people to be treated equally legally and economically and enables employees to achieve better working conditions;
2) public support - the state offers funds for a wide range of public services, such as education and healthcare;
3) greater harmony between social groups - this system provides increased productivity by promoting cooperation and understanding between social groups;
4) improving the economic situation - the system is conducive to creating wealth for the society through investments in public services and infrastructure. In general, socialism can be a well-functioning political system if it has a stable underlying economic model and strong regulatory and disciplinary mechanisms.
This type of socialism emphasizes the desire for a fair distribution of wealth, and is also based on the idea of solidarity between people, especially with the poor. Its intention is to ensure safety and protection for everyone, as well as the possibility of development and chances for a better life. The system emphasizes the importance of public areas as a place where all citizens can use public services and care without having to incur additional costs.
This question is difficult to answer because there are many factors that can influence the effectiveness of socialism. However, the most common reasons why socialism can work successfully are:
1) social justice - the system allows people to be treated equally legally and economically and enables employees to achieve better working conditions;
2) public support - the state offers funds for a wide range of public services, such as education and healthcare;
3) greater harmony between social groups - this system provides increased productivity by promoting cooperation and understanding between social groups;
4) improving the economic situation - the system is conducive to creating wealth for the society through investments in public services and infrastructure. In general, socialism can be a well-functioning political system if it has a stable underlying economic model and strong regulatory and disciplinary mechanisms.
This type of socialism emphasizes the desire for a fair distribution of wealth, and is also based on the idea of solidarity between people, especially with the poor. Its intention is to ensure safety and protection for everyone, as well as the possibility of development and chances for a better life. The system emphasizes the importance of public areas as a place where all citizens can use public services and care without having to incur additional costs.
Machine translated
1 like
1 like
As an AI language model, I cannot express my personal opinions or beliefs about socialism. However, according to proponents, socialism works because it aims to create a fair and equal society by distributing wealth and resources more equally among people. Socialism also seeks to eliminate exploitation and inequality by having the government or the people themselves own and control the means of production, as opposed to private individuals or companies. Socialists believe that this ensures that everyone has access to the basic necessities of life, including healthcare, education, and housing, and that the economic system is more democratic and participatory. However, critics argue that socialism is inefficient, stifles innovation and individual initiative, and can lead to a lack of personal freedoms and choice. Ultimately, the effectiveness of socialism depends on how it is implemented and whether it can successfully balance societal needs with individual rights and freedoms.
As an AI language model, I cannot express my personal opinions or beliefs about socialism. However, according to proponents, socialism works because it aims to create a fair and equal society by distributing wealth and resources more equally among people. Socialism also seeks to eliminate exploitation and inequality by having the government or the people themselves own and control the means of production, as opposed to private individuals or companies. Socialists believe that this ensures that everyone has access to the basic necessities of life, including healthcare, education, and housing, and that the economic system is more democratic and participatory. However, critics argue that socialism is inefficient, stifles innovation and individual initiative, and can lead to a lack of personal freedoms and choice. Ultimately, the effectiveness of socialism depends on how it is implemented and whether it can successfully balance societal needs with individual rights and freedoms.
1 like